Arch support can be a lifesaver for anyone, especially for those who suffer from foot pain or foot conditions. For many, it addresses foot pain and heel pain effectively. But, how much support does the arch really need? And can too much arch support cause plantar fasciitis and other issues?
Let’s start at the beginning.
Understanding arch support and foot health
To answer the question, ‘can too much arch support cause plantar fasciitis?, we first need to discuss how the foot is built.
Foot structure
The structure of the foot is a complex network of bones, ligaments, tendons and muscles that work together to support both movement and balance. And it is anything but flat.
Because feet come in all shapes and sizes, understanding your individual foot structure, including whether you might have wide feet, can help you choose footwear that offers proper support and comfort. Check out our guide on how to tell if you have wide feet.
One of the foot’s key components is the arch – a curved structure that runs along the bottom of the foot, from the heel to the toes. The arch acts like a natural spring that helps absorb shock and support your body weight as you walk, run, or stand. When your foot hits the ground, the arch helps distribute the pressure evenly and acts as a shock absorber, making sure the force isn’t concentrated in one area.
Dr. Steven Gershman, DPM, explains that the plantar fascia is a web-like, thick band of tissue that runs along the bottom of the foot and connects the heel to the toes [1]. "When the arch is at maximal height, the fascia is shorter as the foot is shorter. As a person stands and the arch drops, the foot lengthens and stretches, elongating and tightening the fascia." This means that as the arch drops with each step, it stretches the plantar fascia. This stretching is an essential part of your foot's movement, but if the arch doesn't function properly, it can put extra strain on the plantar fascia, leading to pain and conditions like plantar fasciitis.
Dr. Gershman adds that the plantar fascia is “slow to heal from injury” because it has limited blood and nerve supply. This makes it more challenging to recover from strains, especially when it’s stretched too far or overused.
The arch
The actual shape of the arch varies from person to person. Some people have low arches, or flat feet, while others have a natural, or medium arch, and some have high arches. Still, no matter which arch type you have, arch support can help maintain proper foot alignment and distribute weight evenly to prevent strain and discomfort.
Where the arch type does have influence is in the level of support needed. Flat feet often need extra support to prevent overpronation (the excessive inward rolling of the foot as you walk or run) and discomfort, while high arches typically need cushioning to absorb shock. Those with a normal arch will benefit from moderate support to maintain foot health, particularly if they lead an active lifestyle.
How arch support affects foot alignment
Arch support helps stabilize the foot by preventing excessive stress on the plantar fascia. When properly balanced, support reduces strain and improves foot function, making walking and standing more comfortable. It also helps maintain overall alignment.
When the arch is properly supported, the foot stays in a more neutral position, which helps correct gait, aligns the feet with the legs and back, and reduces impact and pressure on the joints. This can improve posture and prevent strain from traveling up the kinetic chain, potentially alleviating discomfort in the knees, hips, and lower back.
But there is such a thing as too much support, as it can interfere with natural foot mechanics. Overcorrecting the arch can lead to unnatural pressure distribution, which is likely to cause discomfort and even pain. This can be especially harmful to those with plantar fasciitis, since inappropriate footwear or excessive arch support can contribute to worsening symptoms rather than alleviating them [2] [3].
Still, can too much arch support cause plantar fasciitis?
Can over-support lead to plantar fasciitis?
The short answer is: yes.
Wondering how can too much arch support cause plantar fasciitis? It’s simple: If the level of support is too high or too rigid, it may add more pressure to the plantar fascia instead of relieving it, potentially worsening plantar fasciitis or even causing it.
But plantar fasciitis isn't the only problem that can develop. If your arch support is too aggressive, it can force your ankle into an unnatural position, causing it to roll outward – a condition called supination. This misalignment affects weight distribution, putting unnecessary stress on the outer edge of your foot and your arch.
Another concern is muscle strength. Relying too much on rigid arch supports can weaken the foot’s natural stabilizing muscles, because the foot becomes dependent on external support. Over time, this rigidity can cause you to lose balance and stability, making your feet more prone to injury.
Like anything else in life, the key to good arch support and successful treatment of foot conditions like plantar fasciitis is balance. To help absorb shock rather than add stress, your shoes or orthotics should be able to distribute your weight evenly across your foot.
Footwear plays a significant role in the treatment of plantar fasciitis and in preventing pain. Choose support that matches your arch type and activity level, ensuring that it enhances rather than disrupts your foot function. And before jumping into specialized insoles, it’s worth revisiting the basics—can shoes cause plantar fasciitis when they lack structure, support, or cushioning altogether? Selecting the right shoes for plantar fasciitis with appropriate support is essential for comfort and health.
Signs your arch support is too high
Here are some common red flags that your arch support may be too high:
-
Arch pain – Instead of providing relief, excessive support can create new pain in the arch.
-
Heel pain – When the arch is too high it can change how pressure is distributed, leading to discomfort in the heel.
-
Midfoot discomfort – A high arch support can make walking or standing uncomfortable by putting too much stress on the middle of your foot.
-
Knee, hip, or back pain – Too much arch support throws your feet out of alignment with your legs, potentially creating a chain reaction that causes pain in your joints and back.
If you’re experiencing these symptoms, it might be time to reassess your arch support. The right fit should feel comfortable and natural, not like your foot is being forced into an unnatural position.
Finding the right level of support
No two feet are the same, so naturally, neither is the support they need.
Your foot shape and activity level are the two aspects that should determine the right arch support for you. As mentioned earlier, if the support is too rigid, it can limit natural movement and cause discomfort. If it’s too soft, your foot won’t get the stability it needs, which can lead to plantar fasciitis pain and misalignment. Similarly, if your arch support is too high it may put extra pressure on your arch, while support that is too low might not provide enough lift, putting more strain on your arch and messing with your foot’s alignment.
The best option is moderate, adaptive support, as this type stabilizes your foot while allowing it to move naturally, helps treat existing discomfort, and reduces the risk of strain or injury caused by improper support.
If you’re unsure which support level is best for you, keep in mind that with each Orthofeet shoe, you can adjust the height of the support using the Arch Booster, which can be placed under the orthotic insole to enhance arch support.
Additionally, it’s always best to consult a podiatrist or specialist. They can assess your arch height, foot mechanics, and any existing conditions to recommend the best insoles or orthopedic shoes for your needs. If you’re shopping for new footwear and unsure what to prioritize, our guide on how to choose plantar fasciitis shoes breaks down the essential features to look for, from arch support to cushioning.
How to choose the best insoles and shoes
Choosing the best insole depends on your arch height and specific foot concerns. Here’s what insoles can do for your specific arch types, plus two examples of how they can make a difference for certain foot conditions:
-
For low arches (flat feet) – Structured support helps prevent overpronation and maintains proper foot alignment.
-
For high arches – Extra cushioning absorbs impact and relieves pressure on the heel and forefoot.
-
For plantar fasciitis – Insoles with targeted arch support and heel cushioning reduce strain on the plantar fascia.
-
For foot fatigue or metatarsal pain – Shock-absorbing cushioning helps distribute pressure evenly and reduces discomfort.
Pairing our high-quality insoles for plantar fasciitis with the right shoes is even more effective. Read our guide on how to measure insoles for shoes to ensure you’re choosing the correct fit and functionality for your shoes.
Orthofeet shoes are expertly designed to provide a well-balanced combination of support and cushioning, helping to prevent foot pain and improve overall comfort. All our shoes come complete with:
-
Premium removable orthotic insoles: The closest thing to custom, designed with anatomical arch support and multi-layer foam to align your body and cushion from heel to toe. Easily removable if you need to insert your own custom orthotics.
-
Shock-absorbing cushioning: The ergonomic sole and Ortho-Cushion™ System soften impacts, making each step feel easier and adding a little spring to your stride.
-
Customizable fit: Fitting spacers let you fine-tune the space inside your shoe, helping to achieve the perfect fit and prevent slippage, which is especially helpful if one foot is slightly shorter than the other.
-
Arch Booster System: If you need extra support, the Arch Booster can be added under the insole to enhance arch support and reduce pressure on the heel and ball of the foot.
-
Wide toe box, and extended widths and depth: A roomy, pressure-free fit for toes, perfect for bunions, hammertoes, and swollen feet, with multiple width options up to Extra Extra Wide.
-
Soft, protective interior: Thick, padded, and completely seam-free to prevent irritation – ideal for sensitive feet, including those with neuropathy, diabetes, or arthritis.
-
Flexible or non-constricting uppers: Materials that contour to your foot’s shape or that accommodate any foot type for a personalized, pressure-free fit.
Tips for preventing foot pain
If you're already dealing with discomfort, learning how to treat plantar fasciitis at home can help you ease symptoms through simple stretches, ice therapy, and supportive footwear. Taking care of your feet doesn’t have to be complicated. A few simple habits can go a long way in keeping them pain-free:
-
Wear supportive shoes – Choose shoes with good arch support and cushioning to reduce strain on your feet.
-
Switch things up – Wearing the same shoes every day can cause your feet to rely on very specific support structures. Rotating between different pairs can help maintain balance and prevent discomfort.
-
Keep moving – Moving regularly helps prevent stiffness and improves circulation. If you’re sitting for long hours, try to find ways to keep your legs active, like stretching your foot and ankle, or taking short walking breaks.
-
Maintain a healthy weight – Extra weight increases the load your feet must carry, which can cause a wide variety of foot problems. Keeping a balanced weight helps reduce unnecessary pressure.
-
Rest when needed – If you spend a lot of time on your feet, give them a break now and then. Elevating your feet can reduce swelling and ease muscle fatigue [2].
-
Ice sore spots – Ice is a quick and effective way to soothe pain and reduce inflammation [2].
-
Keep your feet clean – Good hygiene helps keep your feet healthy and free from infection. Wash and dry your feet daily, and don’t forget to moisturize to avoid dry, cracked skin.
Exercises to strengthen foot muscles
Stronger feet mean better support, improved stability, and less pain. Consider implementing a few simple stretching and exercise routines regularly to strengthen your foot muscles, improve flexibility, and even prevent conditions like plantar fasciitis.
Here are some easy exercises to try. Repeat each one as long as comfortable:
-
Toe curls – strengthens the small muscles in your feet, improving arch support.
-
-
Sit up straight in a chair with both feet flat on the floor.
-
Curl up your toes as if trying to grab the floor, then use your toes to drag your foot forward.
-
-
Calf raises – strengthens your calves and reduces strain on your plantar fascia.
-
-
Stand with your feet shoulder-width apart and slowly lift your heels until you’re on your toes.
-
Hold for a few seconds, then lower back down.
-
-
Towel stretch – helps relieve tightness in your arch and Achilles tendon.
-
-
Sit with your legs extended and wrap a towel around the ball of your foot.
-
Gently pull the towel toward you.
-
-
Plantar fascia stretch – improves flexibility and reduces arch pain.
-
-
Cross one foot over your opposite knee.
-
Grab the base of your toes, and gently pull them back toward your shin.
-
-
Marble pickup – improves toe strength and coordination while supporting the arch.
-
-
Place 10-15 marbles on the floor.
-
Use your toes to pick them up and drop them into a container.
-
-
Towel scrunches – strengthens the muscles that support your arch and enhances foot stability.
-
-
Sitting straight with your feet flat on the ground, lay a small towel flat under your feet
-
Use your toes to scrunch up the towel.
-
-
Single-leg stand – improves balance and strengthens the small stabilizing muscles in your feet and ankles.
-
-
Stand on one foot for 20-30 seconds, then switch sides.
-
For an extra challenge, try closing your eyes or standing on a cushioned surface.
-
-
Heel-to-toe walk – enhances coordination, strengthens foot muscles, and improves stability.
-
-
Walk in a straight line, placing your heel directly in front of your toes with each step.
-
Take the first step toward pain-free feet with Orthofeet
Orthofeet shoes are specifically made to support your feet, whether you're dealing with plantar fasciitis or other foot conditions. With features like adjustable arch support and multi-layered cushioning, our designed to keep your feet comfortable throughout the day. Plus, with wide toe boxes and breathable materials, your feet get the space and airflow they need.
===================
[1] Benjamin K. Buchanan, Reddog E. Sina, Donald Kushner. Plantar Fasciitis. National Library of Medicine. Updated January 7, 2024. Accessed March 20, 2025.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK431073/
[2] Umar Haddaya, Idrees Wajeeha, Umar Wardah, Khalil Anish, Rizvi Zuhair A. Impact of Routine Footwear on Foot Health: A Study on Plantar Fasciitis. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care. July 2022. Accessed March 20, 2025.
[3] Jenette Restivo, medically reviewed by Robert H. Shmerling, MD. Plantar fasciitis: Symptoms, causes, and treatments. Harvard Health Publishing. November 3, 2023. Accessed March 20, 2025.
https://www.health.harvard.edu/pain/plantar-fasciitis-symptoms-causes-and-treatments